Parking in front of the store is limited and may be hard to get out as you have to back out into the street, but it wasn't bad. There were so many pie flavors. We got the Macadamia Nut and the Blueberry Pina Colada. Omg, the blueberry pina colada pie is TO DIE FOR. I wish I could go back and just buy frozen boxes and bring it back to California because this was so fragrant and well done. The service is so nice, and they even have silver tupperware for customers to dine in with rather than the plastic ones. I've been back home for 2 months but I'm still dreaming of their pies.

Coming here for dessert is a must! Their pies are so unique and also so yummy. My favorite is the coconut cream pie. My parents who do not even like coconut enjoyed this pie so much! We all agree that we would get this pie again. They make their pies fresh every day. The lady who helped us was very sweet and kind. She was very patient with us and thoughtful. There were no singular slices left since it was the end of the day. So we bought a whole pie. She cut it up for us and gave us to go forks and plates and went above and beyond.

Outrageously delicious. The lilikoi mango pie was so insanely fresh and delicious, and the crust that accompanied it was perfect. We also tried the coconut cream pie, which was unlike anything I've ever tasted. There were at least 10 other sweet pie options to choose from, as well as 4+ savory pies. You can buy by the slice, or the two different sized full pies. One of the best parts of our trip to Kauai, hands down.

Delicious slice coconut cream eaten in the shop this afternoon. We were there at a very quiet time, and enjoyed looking at all the charming merchandise. Service was friendly, BUT I ended up with coconut cream although the employee confirmed I'd changed my order to Mango Lilikoa (passion fruit). Would visit again!

Best find in Kauai! Absolutely delicious pies - my family loved the macadamia nut pie (like pecan pie, but better) and the lillikoi cheesecake, we also liked mocha lava brownie pie. They have a huge variety of other pies available by the slice (can add whipped cream or vanilla ice cream) or whole "baby" pies (normal pie size), which can be fresh or frozen to bring home, and any pie slice can be made into an amazing pie shake (way better than Sonic's pie shakes, which are already delicious), as well as edible cookie dough, lillikoi bars, savory pies, and more. You can enjoy your dessert in the cute shop or take away. Also saw them at the Wednesday market at The Shops at Kukui'ula in Poipu. Get some pie (in pie or shake form)!

Omg! If you like pie! Both sweet and savory. They do take and bake or will bake for you. So have dessert pie while They bake you shepherds pie! There are over 50 flavors and different one by the slide per day. Locally made with great service and fun little gift shop too. Dessert first!

The best discoveries happen when you're traveling in Kauai with your family, spot a pie shop on the highway and everyone shouts "bakery---pie--stop!" So we stopped and had a delightful breakfast snack of 4 different pie slices: coconut cream, blueberry pina colada, Lilikoi cheesecake, and mango Lilikoi. There's have a great selection of pies, either by the slice or as a whole pie to buy. Wow, everyone loved their choices, and because we did try a bite of each other's selection, the family favorite was the Lilikoi cheesecake! They also have a savory pie menu of frozen pies to take home and bake! Service from the gal was friendly and nice. And the shop is cute and there are lots of extra trinkety Kauai things to look at. We'll try to make it over one more time before we leave and try other flavors of pie...or I'll pick the Lilikoi cheesecake for myself next time. We love supporting local small businesses and The Right Slice has a delicious product for dessert lovers. It truly is a great stop for anyone with a sweet tooth or craving for pie to try!

Food: we got the famous Mango Lilikoi, Blueberry Pina Colada pie, macadamia nut and cheese cake. I have to say if you're here for the signature and Hawaiian fruity taste, go for the former 2 flavors, but the simple flavors are much of my type of tea! I love how not so sweet of them and very crispy comparing with the moisture fruit fillings. Service: nice and simple; hard to find parking though; only 3 lots available in front of the shop. Ambiance: comfortable and cool.

Wanted to have lilikoi pie while on Kauai and saw the sign for this cute little shop located on Kaumuali'i Hwy in Kalaheo near Brick Oven Pizza . They serve both sweet and savory pies. The lime pie filling was PERFECT in tartness, sweetness, and texture (reminded me of my grandma's specialty pie.) Crust not as much. It was hard to cut with a fork so ended up breaking it off and biting it.. The mango lilikoi pie was also broke da mouth! Beautiful soft slices of ripe mango with just the right tartness and this time the crust was flaky, buttery, and perfect! One of the pricier pies I've had, but also one of the best! You get what you pay for! Glad I got 2 slices ! Filling:5 stars Crust: 3 & 5 = 4 stars Price: 4 Selection:5 Overall: 5